The Commission conducts evaluations of associate judges of the District of Columbia Court of Appeals and the Superior Court of the District of Columbia who seek reappointment upon the expiration of their terms. The Commission issued the evaluation reports listed below which are available to the public.
The following PDF files are the reports on each judge's reappointment evaluation by year:
2023
- Judge Alfred S. Irving, Jr. – Superior Court
- Judge Anthony C. Epstein – Superior Court
- Judge Heidi M. Pasichow – Superior Court
2021
- Chief Judge Anna Blackburne-Rigsby – Court of Appeals
- Judge Jennifer M. Anderson – Superior Court
2020
- Judge Juliet J. McKenna – Superior Court
- Judge Laura A. Cordero – Superior Court
- Judge José M. López – Superior Court
2018
- Judge Fern Flanagan Saddler – Superior Court
- Judge Craig S. Iscoe – Superior Court
- Judge J. Michael Ryan – Superior Court
2017
- Judge Robert R. Rigsby - Superior Court
2016
- Judge Erik P. Christian – Superior Court
- Judge Maurice A. Ross – Superior Court
- Judge Lynn Leibovitz – Superior Court
2015
- Judge Gerald I. Fisher – Superior Court
- Judge Michael Rankin – Superior Court
- Judge John Ramsey Johnson – Superior Court
- Judge Thomas J. Motley – Superior Court
- Judge John M. Mott – Superior Court
2014
- Judge Eric T. Washington - Court of Appeals
- Judge Stephen H. Glickman - Court of Appeals
- Judge Hiram E. Puig-Lugo - Superior Court
2013
- Judge Patricia A. Broderick - Superior Court
- Judge Neal E. Kravitz - Superior Court
- Judge Melvin R. Wright - Superior Court
2012
- Judge John M. Campbell - Superior Court
- Judge Anita Josey-Herring - Superior Court
2011
- Judge Robert E. Morin - Superior Court
2010
- Judge Inez Smith Reid - Court of Appeals
- Judge Linda Kay Davis - Superior Court
- Judge Ronna Lee Beck - Superior Court
2009
- Judge Vanessa Ruiz - Court of Appeals
- Judge Judith Bartnoff - Superior Court
- Judge Zoe Bush - Superior Court
- Judge Rhonda Reid Winston - Superior Court
2008
- Judge Russell F. Canan - Superior Court
2007
- Judge Frederick H. Weisberg - Superior Court